Payment and Disputes | 7 min read

Construction payment disputes: what your options are and how to prepare

Jon Evans, founder of Validate · 25 March 2026 · 7 min read

Your PM has certified 180k on your 280k application. No explanation. No breakdown. Just a payment certificate with a number that's 100k short of what you submitted.

You've got wages to pay on Friday. Materials on 30-day terms. And a main contractor who won't pick up the phone. This is where most M&E subcontractors find out whether their records are good enough.

Your rights under the Construction Act 1996

The Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, as amended by the Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act 2009 (together, the Construction Act), gives you some real teeth. Every construction contract must provide an adequate mechanism for working out what payments become due and when, and a final date for payment (section 110). Where a contract doesn't, the Scheme for Construction Contracts fills the gaps.

The contract must also provide for a payment notice. Either the payer (or a person named in the contract) gives a notice, no later than five days after the payment due date, saying what sum it considers due and how that sum is calculated, or you as payee give a notice with the same details (section 110A(1) to (3)). If the payer wants to pay less than the sum notified, it must give a pay less notice, setting out the lower sum and the basis for it, within the prescribed period before the final date for payment (section 111(3) to (5)).

If the payer gives no payment notice and no pay less notice in time, and you have given your own notice of the sum you say is due (for example a payment application that meets the Act and the contract), the sum in your notice is the notified sum (section 110B(2) to (4)). The payer must pay the notified sum on or before the final date for payment (section 111(1)). Where the payer did give a payment notice but no pay less notice, the sum in the payer's notice is what it must pay. Whether your own application counts as a compliant notice depends on your contract, so check it and take advice.

If the notified sum isn't paid in full by the final date for payment, you may have the right to suspend performance of some or all of your obligations (section 112(1)). It is a conditional right, not an absolute one. You must first give the party in default at least seven days' notice of your intention to suspend, stating the grounds (section 112(2)). The right ends when the payer pays the sum in full (section 112(3)). If you do suspend, the payer is liable for the reasonable costs and expenses you incur as a result (section 112(3A)). Suspension is a serious step. Check your contract and take advice before you serve notice.

Key point: The notified sum rule has conditions. The payer must have given no payment notice and no pay less notice in time, and you must have given your own payment application or notice that meets the Act (section 110B). Only then is the sum in your application the notified sum, payable by the final date for payment (section 111(1)). If the payer gave a payment notice, that notice sets the notified sum.

Your rights under NEC4 specifically

Under NEC4 Option A, the PM assesses the amount due at each assessment date and certifies a payment. The assessment dates and the time allowed to certify are set out in the payment clauses of your subcontract, so check the exact timetable there.

If the PM's assessment is wrong, you don't have to accept it. Your contract sets out how to challenge an assessment and the dispute resolution options, which in NEC4 are in Option W1 or W2. Check the clauses that apply to you.

Option W2 is the adjudication procedure used where the Construction Act applies. The Act gives you the right to refer a dispute to adjudication at any time (section 108(1) and (2)(a)). The adjudicator must reach a decision within 28 days of referral. The adjudicator can extend that by up to 14 days with the referring party's consent, and the parties can agree a longer period (section 108(2)(c) and (d)).

Before you go to adjudication

Adjudication is quicker and usually cheaper than court, but it's not free. Adjudicators usually charge by the hour; ask for their fee terms before you appoint. Your own legal or claims costs come on top. So before you start, do the maths.

Ask yourself three questions:

  1. Is the amount worth fighting for? If you're 10k short, a conversation might be cheaper than a referral. If you're 100k short, you probably don't have a choice.
  2. Do you have the evidence? Contemporaneous records, dated notifications, photos with timestamps. If your evidence is thin, an adjudicator might not find in your favour even if you're right.
  3. Did you follow the contract procedures? Timebars are real. If you notified a CE late, the adjudicator may decide it's time-barred. That's a hard lesson to learn at the hearing.

Talk to a construction solicitor before you refer. Some offer a short first conversation to assess whether your case has legs, and it usually costs far less than getting it wrong.

Building your evidence file

Your adjudicator wants to see a clear story. They want dates, documents, and a logical sequence. They don't want a box of disorganised paper.

Here's what you need to pull together:

Organise it chronologically. Put a timeline at the front. Make it easy for the adjudicator to follow your story. They've got 28 days and a stack of cases. Don't make them work to understand yours.

A common reason claims are lost

It's often not bad work. It's often not even wrong valuations. A common reason M&E subcontractors lose claims is late notification.

Under NEC4, you've got eight weeks to notify a compensation event after becoming aware of it. Miss that window and, under clause 61.3, you are not entitled to a change to the Prices, the Completion Date or a Key Date, unless the PM should have notified the event to you but did not. The clause is strict. Check the wording in your own contract.

Say a valid compensation event is notified nine weeks after the contractor became aware of it. That is one week late, and one week can be the difference between getting paid and writing it off.

The fix is simple but it requires discipline. Log every event as it happens. Notify the same day. Don't wait for the PM to acknowledge it. Don't wait until you know the cost. Notify first, assess later.

The other common failure is poor records. You know the work was done. Your lads know the work was done. But if you can't show an adjudicator dated, location-stamped evidence, it's your word against theirs. Adjudicators decide on evidence, not feelings.

Start your records on day one. Not when a dispute starts. By then it's too late. The best evidence is the evidence you didn't know you'd need.

Records ready for adjudication

Validate creates contemporaneous site records from day one. Timestamped, with GPS location where the phone allows it, and PM-approved. Available to export if you need them.

Start your free trial

Further reading